While this is a fascinating story of the missing and doomed Franklin expedition, I was quite struck by the overt racism against the Inook. They had the answers as to location of at least one ship, but they were dismissed as barbaric by the next few rescue missions. There were one or two explorers who took them somewhat seriously and followed their stories and discovered there oral stories were true. It also highlights Canada's treatment of the Inook by forcing them to change their way of life and locations. Education and normal clothing, rather than animal fur and the schooling of nature survival. I found that a sad part of the book, but a vital part.
Interesting and written in a journalistic style. The maps, however, were inadequate.
Thoroughly fascinating and wonderfully written. Watson recounts over 160 years of history of one of the great maritime mysteries in fabulous detail. No punches are pulled and no sugar coating is given. This story is as visceral as it is kinetic and is a testament to human ego, vulnerability, sacrifice and, ultimately, perseverance and humility. My only caveats are that while Watson covers a few of the ancient expeditions, he doesn't cover them all. I wanted to know more. Also, given all its detail, I expected more maps, photos, and complete manifests of crew and cargo for each ship.
The Franklin Expedition continues to be a story that fascinates, particularly through the many unsuccessful follow-up expeditions that sought to find answers to what happened to Franklin and his men. Watson's ICE GHOSTS tries to highlight those expeditions, as well as the long oral tradition of the Inuit and the Franklin shipwrecks.
Unfortunately, ICE GHOSTS suffers from trying to cram too much in. Nearly 200 pages of description of the Franklin Expedition itself still leaves many questions unanswered; the 150 years of expeditions that followed get short shrift. I wished for more maps, more photos, more description of the men who kept coming to search. So many of the people are fascinating that we the reader wish for more time spent.
King_of_the_Squirrels thinks this title is suitable for 16 years and over
There are no summaries for this title yet.
There are no notices for this title yet.
There are no quotes for this title yet.